Eating With Emma

Eat, drink and be merry like you're in a 'Home Alone' movie

Here are local versions of the memorable food and beverages featured in the classic Hollywood holiday film franchise.


Image courtesy of Walt Disney Studios
  • Arts + Entertainment
  • Eat + Drink
  • Share

If you’re like me, you grew up watching "Home Alone" and wondering how on Earth a whole family could manage to misplace a child not once but twice. 

I wasn't home alone for any holiday. I was always with a small group, so the notion of losing someone in the group was far-fetched. With the basketball schedule of me and my sister ruling December like a slightly aggressive elf, it was just my parents, my Mimi and us spending Christmas day together. (Wouldn't trade it for the world!) 

But at night, we were adopted into The Brown Family Christmas, thanks to my parents' best friends. They opened their doors to anyone who didn’t have a place to go. What if Kevin McCallister from "Home Alone" had been invited? Let’s just say I think he could have left the blowtorch at home.

I carried the tradition of welcoming any Kevin McCallister to Thanksgiving, if not Christmas, when I moved to Florida. While I can deeply respect the notion of doing whatever you want, whenever you want, I just think the holidays are better spent with people you love, eating good food and having even better drinks ... I mean, conversations.

Still, I'd love to go on an unexpected trip, use my parents' credit card and explore a new city. So, I pretended to do just that in Sarasota as we close 2025; I found local versions of "Home Alone" classics.

And to all "ya filthy animals" (a "Home Alone" catchphrase, ICYMI) who’ve become part of my extended foodie family, thank you for not letting me sit at the table alone this holiday season, or any season for that matter.


Patellini's Pizza

149 Main St., Sarasota; 941-957-6433; Patellinis.com

Family-owned and operated Patellini's is the perfect place to grab a NY slice (or whole pie).
Family-owned and operated Patellini's is the perfect place to grab a New York slice (or whole pie).
Courtesy image

"A lovely cheese pizza, just for me." If I had a Buzz in my life, you'd best believe I would push him off and not let him hog a cheese pizza at any family function. He could go to Patellini's and order an ooey-gooey New York-style cheese slice ($4) for himself while I devour the pie ($17.50 and up) by myself, just like Kevin. And if anyone out there has a limo willing to whisk me around town to admire Christmas lights while I drip pizza grease down my sweater, dab marinara from my lips and stretch each perfectly cheesy slice toward cinematic glory, I certainly wouldn’t say no to the full "Home Alone" experience.


Ocean Prime Sarasota

501 Quay Commons, Sarasota; 941-404-1024; Ocean-Prime.com/Locations-Menus/Sarasota

Kevin McCallister may have had a microwavable mac & cheese meal, but this big kid is going to Ocean Prime for black truffle mac & cheese ($18).
Kevin McCallister may have had a microwavable mac-and-cheese meal, but this big kid is going to Ocean Prime for black truffle mac and cheese ($18).
Courtesy image

"Bless this highly nutritious microwavable macaroni and cheese dinner and the people who sold it on sale. Amen." Consider this the adult version of "Home Alone" where we leave the microwave behind and step into an elevated level of mac and cheese we all deserve. Your choice of indulgence: the decadent black truffle mac and cheese ($18) or the show-stopping baked lobster mac and cheese ($45), packed with whole Maine lobster and creamy Tillamook cheddar. 


Crepetopia

4921 Ringwood Meadow, Sarasota; 941-365-9766; CrepetopiaOfficial.com

Crepetopia is open Monday through Thursday 9AM – 9PM, Friday – Sunday: 10AM – 10PM.
Crepetopia offers that over-the-top ice cream experience known to viewers of "Home Alone.".
Courtesy image

"Two scoops, sir?", said the butler. "Two? Make it three or four, or sixteen. I'm not driving!" I’m ready to take the entire menu home, throw on my pajamas, snag a giant red napkin (aka bib) and sink into the couch for hours, Kevin-style, with his Crunch Gators, Pepsi and a massive bowl of ice cream. Start with a classic banana split ($7.25 and up) or opt for a delicious no-mess option like a milkshake ($7.95), available in chocolate, cookies and cream, vanilla, strawberry, chocolate brownie, dirt 'n’ worms or s’mores. Honestly, I’d happily pretend I’m defending my dessert fortress from would-be thieves, one spoonful (or sip) at a time.


Casa Masa

2773 Bee Ridge Road Sarasota; 941-922-9078; 4862 S. Tamiami Trail, Sarasota; 941-921-0578; 5214 Ocean Blvd., Siesta Key; 941-365-9911; CasaMasa-SRQ.com

Casa Masa's corn Star cocktail (Nixta licor de elote, Jarritos Mineragua, fresh lemon juice, and a truffle popcorn sidecar).
Casa Masa's Corn Star cocktail (Nixta licor de elote, Jarritos Mineragua, fresh lemon juice, and a truffle popcorn sidecar).
Courtesy image

"I made my family disappear!" And then jumps on his parents' bed with popcorn. Popcorn has always been a little nostalgia passed down from my dad to me, and from my husband's father to him. So, it’s always in stock at our home. But unlike Kevin, we haven’t taken the leap and jumped on the bed with a giant tub of popcorn. Honestly? That’s a lot to clean up. Unlike the McCallisters, I don’t have a vacation budget big enough to cover the chaos or a housemaid to bail me out. Instead, I head to Casa Masa for my grown-up version of a popcorn treat: the Corn Star cocktail ($15) made with Nixta licor de elote, Jarritos Mineragua, fresh lemon juice and a truffle popcorn sidecar.


Clarabell Cookies

6564 Superior Ave., Sarasota; 941-923-1742; Clarabellcookies.com

Clarabell Cookies has premium natural cookies, from the classics to new favorites, like cinnamon roll and toffee pretzel chip.
Clarabell Cookies has premium natural cookies, from the classics to new favorites, like cinnamon roll and toffee pretzel chip.
Courtesy image

"I'd like a hotel room please, with an extra large bed, a TV and one of those little refrigerators you have to open with a key." It might not be the most iconic meal in "Home Alone," but every time the mini-fridge popped up on my screen, I couldn’t help but drool over the chocolate chip cookies wrapped in cellophane. I’d watch and wonder what I had to do in my next life to score room service on someone else’s tab. Now, I make the pilgrimage to Gulf Gate, where after one bite at Clarabell Cookies, I get that same delicious sense of exclusivity I dreamed about as a kid. Unless Santa drops a hotel room and room service down my chimney, this is the closest I’ll get to my "Home Alone" fantasy. And if Kevin McCallister could have walked into Clarabell and snagged a cookie, I think the movie might have been a little shorter and a lot sweeter. 

 

author

Emma Burke Jolly

Emma Burke Jolly has worked at Observer Media Group since 2018 as the digital fulfillment specialist. Originally from Connecticut, this Gulf Coast transplant loves being by the water, reminiscing about what Longboat Key looked like in 1990, navigating life with her husband and their two Maine Coon cats, and sharing her foodie findings with you.

Latest News

Sponsored Health Content

Sponsored Content