Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Eating with Emma

Up your lunch game with Sarasota's best sandwiches

Celebrate National Sandwich Day on Nov. 3 at these local stops.

Mirna's Cuban Cuisine has some of the best sandwiches in town.
Mirna's Cuban Cuisine has some of the best sandwiches in town.
Photo by Emma Burke Jolly
  • Arts + Entertainment
  • Eat + Drink
  • Share

The art of sandwich making is something our cultural community doesn’t talk much about. But there is true beauty in creating a great lunchtime staple with the best bread, a collection of cheeses, mouthwatering deli meats and crunchy and creamy add-ons.

To celebrate National Sandwich Day, coming up on Nov. 3, I sampled some of the best sammies since sliced bread. Here are some local masterpieces: 

Main Street Sandwich Bar

1944 Main St., Sarasota; 941-955-8733;

This Main Street eatery makes you feel like you’ve walked into a different decade. Grab a foodie friend, plop into a booth or slide up to the bar and get ready to dig in. Fun fact? You can choose from over 50 sandwiches — or make your own if that tickles your tummy.

Main Street Sandwich Bar's Myan sandwich ($12.95) with jalapeno dressing.
Photo by Emma Burke Jolly

Incredible Italian: The Famous Italian ($11.50) is made of salami, ham, provolone cheese, tomatoes, chopped peppers, onions and the bar’s own unique blend of oil, garlic and spices on a toasted bun. The creation was inspired by the original owner Thea’s hometown of Florence, Italy, and might I say, “Molto bene!”

I Loaf You Too: The Mayan ($12.95) with smoked turkey breast, provolone cheese and jalapeno dressing on a kaiser roll topped with lettuce, tomatoes and onions. I ordered this via Uber Eats for lunch last week, and I should have ordered another one for dinner.

Mirna's Cuban Cuisine

7980 N. Tamiami Trail, Sarasota; 941-316-9793;

My dad would devour a good Cubano any time of the day, and I wish I would have taken him to Mirna’s to bite into the best there is. So, this one’s for you, Dad! This cafe crafts homemade Cuban cuisine at a price that simply can’t be beat. 

Mirna's Cuban sandwich
Photo by Emma Burke Jolly

Craving a Cuban: The one, the only, the Cubano ($7.50-$9.50). Whether you’re a local or just moved to the fourth most neighborly city in the U.S, you know what our state sandwich is. Crafted with fantastic ham, savory shredded roast pork, Swiss cheese, pickles and mustard, it's like a taste of Cuba in a sandwich, and I couldn’t be happier for the vacation.

I Loaf You Too: Don’t like pickles? That’s O.K., because coming in at a very close second is the flavorful pan con bistec de puerco ($7.50-$9.50). This pork steak sandwich is served with sautéed onions and shoestring fries. You will want to order another before you take your last bite.

Southside Deli

1825 Hillview St., Sarasota; 941-330-9302;

Located in Southside Village, this quick bite stop has been serving a variety of delicious deli sandwiches, soups, salads and sides (don’t forget breakfast from 7-11 a.m. daily) since 1999 — and they’ve got a great thing going. 

'Tis the season for Southside Deli's cranberry chicken panini ($11.25).
Photo by Emma Burke Jolly

Tis the Season for Sammy’s: Regardless of the calendar, I will order the cranberry chicken panini ($11.25) in the middle of June. Enjoy grilled chicken breast, Boar’s Head bacon, Havarti cheese, spring mix and the secret weapon — cranberry sauce. Thank me later.

I Loaf You Too: Hot Spicy Turkey ($11.25) made with Sausalito turkey, pepperoni, pepper jack cheese, sliced banana peppers and a ravishing remoulade sauce. Pressed to perfection!

Corkscrew Deli

4982 S. Tamiami Trail, Sarasota; 941-825-3955;

A few years ago I looked at my now-husband and said, “I miss the deli sandwiches I used to get back home.” I had been searching for a taste of the tri-state area and all the places that claimed to be a “New York style deli" fell short. That was, until we happened upon Corkscrew Deli. 

The Corkscrew Club ($9.29) always has me doing my foodie dance.
Photo by Emma Burke Jolly

Crazy for Clubs: Corkscrew Club ($9.29) made with sliced chicken, crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo, all double-layered on white toast. This most classic of sandwiches hits the spot, makes me smile and gets me doing my "foodie dance." I can’t wait to order it again.

Corkscrew's New Yorker ($11.99) has me feeling like I’m back in the Big Apple.
Photo by Emma Burke Jolly

I Loaf You Too: The New Yorker ($11.99) with hot pastrami and corned beef (you read that right!) on toasted rye with Swiss cheese and Corkscrew’s own mustard sauce makes me feel like I’m back in the Big Apple.

Faicco's Sandwich Shop

3590 Webber St., Sarasota; 941-960-1395;

You know what I say about sandwiches? The bigger, the better. Fiacco’s takes that statement and hits it out of the park. Originally from New York City, this family-owned business has been serving sandwiches for over 120 years — and they do it right. 

Heroic Hero: You scream, I scream, we all scream for pesto. The chicken pesto hero ($15) is prepared with a seasoned fried chicken cutlet, mozzarella that makes my heart flutter and homemade pesto. If pesto isn’t what your palate wants, any of the heros with a chicken cutlet will banish negativity from your life.

I really, really loaf Faicco's sweet sausage #2 grilled hero ($15).
Courtesy image

I Loaf You Too: There are so many sandwiches to choose from, but I have to go with the sweet sausage No. 2 grilled hero ($15) with spicy broccoli rabe. It will rock your socks.

Anna's Deli

6535 Midnight Pass Road, Siesta Key; 941-349-4888, 8207 Tourist Center Drive, University Park; 941-893-5908;

Anna's Deli has been shelling out sandwiches in Sarasota since 1971.
Courtesy image

This local eatery has been dishing out sandwiches in Sarasota since 1971. A staple among locals, Anna's serves up larger-than-life sammies generously stacked with meats, cheeses and veggies.

Local Love: Surfer ($9.39) with ham, turkey, Swiss cheese and cucumber. As their motto says, “Often imitated, never duplicated,” and they are not wrong. 

I Loaf You Too: Peddler ($9.39) with tuna salad, Swiss cheese and cucumber. If you aren’t a fan, this one will change your mind. Don't miss this oppor-tuna-ty, served on Anna's unique "canned bread."

Hamlet's Eatery

821 Apricot Ave., Sarasota; 941-445-1938;

I adore Hamlet's Eatery Melty MacBeth ($13).
Courtesy image

Located in the courtyard of The Bazaar On Apricot & Lime, this food truck will make you ponder Hamlet's tagline, “To meat or not to meat." Why? Every item on the menu has a vegan option.

Vegan Vote: Mid-summer garden panini ($14) with roasted mushrooms, zucchini, red bell pepper, arugula and vegan mozzarella with a pesto mayo on grilled sourdough. Not vegan? Go for goat cheese and fresh mozzarella. This ooey-gooey sammy makes me one happy camper.

I Loaf You Too: Melty MacBeth ($13). Gruyere, fresh mozzarella with caramelized onion jam on sourdough served with fries or lightly dressed greens. 


Numerous locations,

Our friend in Cleveland asked us if we can ship him one. My brother-in-law hops off the plane at SRQ and immediately asks when we are going to get one. When I told my mom I was writing about sandwiches, she asked, “Are they on the list?” Yes, it's Pub sub time.

It's pub sub time.
Photo by Emma Burke Jolly

Superbly Stacked Sub: My husband is addicted to the Publix chicken tender sub ($10.49 and up). It's packed with their famous hand-breaded chicken tenders with provolone, lettuce and tomato. You can customize like Patrick by choosing tenders tossed in buffalo sauce, replacing provolone with pepper jack and adding green peppers, cucumber and onion.

I Loaf You Too: I devour Publix turkey subs ($8.49 and up). Get the standard turkey, provolone, lettuce and tomato on a white sub roll or do what I do: Choose cheddar, add green and banana peppers, cucumber and lather up that deli sub sauce.



Emma Burke Jolly

Emma Burke Jolly has worked at Observer Media Group since 2018 as the digital fulfillment specialist. Originally from Connecticut, this Gulf Coast transplant loves being by the water, reminiscing about what Longboat Key looked like in 1990, navigating life with her husband and their two Maine Coon cats, and sharing her foodie findings with you.

Latest News