Skip to main content
Longboat Key Wednesday, Aug. 19, 2015 6 years ago

I Scream, You Scream

We all scream for St. Armands ice cream.
by: Kristen Herhold Community Editor

As a journalist, it's normal to get tough assignments. When I found out I had to eat at the six different ice cream shops on St. Armands Circle, I knew I had a grueling task ahead of me: Each ice cream shop has delicious flavors. How could I pick just one?

To get the scoop on the Circle's best ice cream, I spent three weeks sampling its sweetest treats. My conclusion: You can’t go wrong with any store.


Ben and Jerry’s

372 St. Armands Circle

Hours: 11 a.m. to 11 p.m.

Most popular flavor: The Tonight Dough: Caramel and chocolate ice creams with chocolate cookie swirls, chocolate chip cookie dough and peanut butter cookie dough.

The scoop: I love chocolate and cookie dough flavors in ice cream, so I really enjoyed this. It’s perfect for the customer who loves rich, decadent tastes. No bite is the same in this flavor-packed ice cream.

“It’s a very popular flavor,” Manager Peter Quaresima said. “It’s flying off the shelf. It’s been super, super popular. People can’t get enough of it.”

Le Macaron’s gelato sundae, made with violet flower, candy strawberry and vanilla bean gelato flavors, rose petals and Madagascar black vanilla macaroons and whipped cream.


Le Macaron

382 St. Armands Circle

Hours: 10 a.m. to 10 p.m., Sunday to Friday; 10 a.m. to 11 p.m. Saturday

Most popular flavor: Violet Flower

The scoop: What may be the most unique flavor on the Circle, this flower-based, purple ice cream, which is flown in every other week from France, has an indescribably refreshing taste that is light in flavor. I enjoyed it paired with the candy strawberry and vanilla bean gelato flavors.

“Our violet is something you don’t find on the Circle,” employee Blair Henderson said. “It’s something different from any other ice cream or gelato places here. It’s a great place to be for unique flavors.”

Big Olaf owner Dave Tesar with the shop’s most popular flavor, Kahlua Krunch


Big Olaf Creamery

561 N. Washington Drive

Hours: 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Monday to Thursday; 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday; noon to 10 p.m. Sunday

Most popular flavor: Kahlua Krunch, made with Lahlua ice cream and chocolate and mocha chips.

The scoop: I generally don’t enjoy coffee or coffee-flavored treats, but this ice cream is not too overwhelmingly coffee flavored and is perfectly balanced with the chocolate. It’s a rich, indulgent treat for adult ice cream lovers.

“You’ll find nothing better in Sarasota than Kahlua Krunch,” owner Dave Tesar said. “People come from all over to get this flavor, and we make the ice cream right here in Sarasota.”

Sofia Salazar, of Settimi’s Gelato, scoops pistachio gelato.


Settimi’s Gelato

367 St. Armands Circle

Hours: 11 a.m. to 10:30 p.m.

Most popular flavor: Pistachio gelato

The scoop: Pistachio is a classic Italian gelato flavor and is very light and fresh tasting. I usually go for the richer flavors, but I really enjoyed the pistachio here. With chunks of pistachios mixed in, it’s easy to tell how authentic the ingredients are.

“We make everything here, so it’s homemade,” employee Sofia Salazar said. “We use fresh ingredients, and our gelato has less fat than normal ice cream. It’s made every day. We use fresh pistachios, and this was made just a few hours ago.”

Trash Can is one of the Fudge Factory’s most popular flavors.


The winner

Fudge Factory

12 N. Blvd. of Presidents

Hours: 11 a.m. to 11 p.m.

Most popular flavor: Trash Can

Who’d ever thought a flavor named Trash Can would be my favorite on the Circle?

The scoop: Although all six flavors I tried were delicious, this one was my personal favorite. It was by far the most intriguing flavor. I am always the type to get a lot of toppings on my ice cream if given the choice, and the Trash Can is created by throwing all the extra ingredients from other flavors together. From peanut butter cups to brownies, cookie dough and chocolate-covered nuts, every bite is a surprise.

This homemade ice cream is perfect for those who like rich, sweet flavors, and there was so much in there. It was like several different ice cream flavors in one.

“The name is so catchy,” employee Grant Rigel said. “People hear the name and are skeptical at first, but they try it and love it.”

One of Kilwin’s’ most successful flavors is toasted coconut.



312 John Ringling Blvd.

Hours: 8 a.m. to 11 p.m. Sunday to Thursday; 8 a.m. to 11:30 p.m. Friday and Saturday

Most popular flavor: Toasted coconut

The scoop: I’ve always loved coconut, so I’m a big fan of this ice cream. The coconut flavor is complemented well with chocolate chunks, and this is a perfect, not-too-heavy treat.

Join the Neighborhood! Our 100% local content helps strengthen our communities by delivering news and information that is relevant to our readers. Support independent local journalism by joining the Observer's new membership program — The Newsies — a group of like-minded community citizens, like you. Be a Newsie.

Related Stories