Statue ruling questioned


Statue ruling questioned


Date: August 20, 2009
by: Robin Roy | City Editor


After the Public Art Committee rejected a proposal to keep the controversial sculpture “Unconditional Surrender” on the bayfront for at least 10 years, supporters of the sailor statue said they felt committee members had already made up their minds before the Aug. 12 hearing.

“I’m not surprised at the decision,” said Dr. Rich Swier, president of the Sarasota County Veterans Commission. “They were just looking for a reason to turn this down.”

An 88-year-old World War II veteran approached Swier in May wanting to buy “Unconditional Surrender” for $500,000 and donate it to the city, but only if it remains on the bayfront.

The Public Art Committee denied the proposal, ruling that the sculpture did not meet the standards of public art, which dictate, among other things, that the piece must be an original work. Committee members felt because it is modeled after a famed Life magazine photo, it was not an original.

The chairwoman of the Public Art Committee, Virginia Hoffman, has not tried to hide her personal feelings about “Unconditional Surrender,” previously calling it “worse than kitsch.”

But supporters of the sculpture are latching onto user comments on a page on the social networking Web site Facebook. The page is called “Higher Standards for Sarasota,” which is an anti-sailor-statue page.

Some examples of comments on the page include:

“A group seriously believes this gigantic lawn ornament is ‘educating’ the groups of people who come and look at it. Please!”

“I’m just waiting for a big wind from the South to blow that big cartoon into the nearby intersection and block evacuations from Longboat Key.”

The last commenter went on to say elected officials were too busy to understand fine art.

Hoffman posted that the commenter had “good insights.”

Some of her other page comments have caused sculpture supporters to question her impartiality.

The comments include: praising a Sarasota Herald-Tribune letter to the editor in which the author said they feel “ashamed when I gaze at the gaudy” statue.

And references to sculpture opponents as “intelligent, reasonable and rational” and supporters as showing “contempt for artists” and resorting to the “lowest common denominator.”

Hoffman said there is no conflict of interest.

“Being on the board does not supercede my freedom of speech,” she said. “I can say anything to anyone, except the four other people (on the Public Art Committee), because of the Sunshine Laws.”

City Auditor and Clerk Billy Robinson, who oversees the city’s advisory boards, agrees.

“Anybody can express their opinion,” he said.

Although the Art Committee rejected the veteran’s donation, the City Commission gets the final word, and it will hold a public hearing on the issue next month.

Login Register now

Currently 1 Response

  • 1.
  • Frankly, my dears, I don't give a hang what the "Art Committee" thinks about Unconditional Surrender. Unlike the low quality garbage they string along the bay each year, it is beautiful. It certainly beats the Picture Frame (Oh, my, you get a different picture of the bay when you stand in a different place!" ) The same effect can be had from bringing any empty frame from any framing shop. It appears that the 'Art Committee' only loves the inane, pathetic, gross and ugly (remember our little car dance in front of a major building). Having been hit by an 18-wheeler, the last thing I wanted to see was a car wreck every time I visite ddowntown. Of course, everyone has noticed the absolute crowds of visitors having their pictures taken with the other pieces of 'art'. Oh, you haven't? But surely if our lovely nurse and handsome sailor draw the crowds, then the other pieces must be just as popular - right? Nope, they are avoided like the plague or visited by people who fancy themselves to be artists and therefore absolutely MUST support the other sad examples of the Sarasota art scene.

    Leave the Unconditional Surrender alone. For the first time, in my ten years here, I'm actually proud of a piece of REAL art. As Mama used to say, I may not always know art, but I know trash when I see it. The rest of the mess strewn along the bay each year is trash.
  • margie digiovanni
    Thu 20th Aug 2009
    at 12:24pm
Login below to post a comment or click register.
Account E-Mail
forgot password? click here
Speak Your Mind Below!


Subscribe to our eNewsletters
1970 Main Street, Sarasota, FL 34236 941-366-3468

Copyright 2015 The Observer Group Inc., All Rights Reserved