Benches to be removed from park


Benches to be removed from park


Date: May 19, 2011
by: Robin Roy | City Editor


The first citizens to officially ask the new City Commission to help with what they saw as a serious problem saw a quick resolution.

Three people asked commissioners Monday to remove the three remaining benches in Selby Five Points Park.

“(The homeless) have set up a home office there,” said downtown resident Jim Lampl. “While it’s legal to use the benches, they’re there for six-to-eight-hour shifts.”

About a month-and-a-half ago, the city removed six benches from the park, because residents had complained that the benches attracted transients and panhandlers and allowed them to mass together, which intimidates some citizens and tourists.

“We were hoping for a more favorable outcome, but it hasn’t happened,” Lampl said. “It’s not thinning out the masses of transients.”

Peter Fanning, president of the Downtown Sarasota Condo Association, consistently had been opposed to removing benches from the park, because residents also used them.

However, after seeing little change in the number of transients at the park, he changed his stance and also asked commissioners to take away the remaining benches.

“I said, ‘OK, I’ll try it your way,’” Fanning said he told supporters of bench removal.

Pat Westerhouse, a member of the Downtown Improvement District and manager at Casto Properties, which owns the Whole Foods complex from Lemon Avenue to Central Avenue, agreed that something needed to be done.

“We’ve been a magnet for transient traffic,” she said. “Leasing has been very tough for us. Removing the remaining benches would be extremely helpful.”

Less than two hours after hearing those requests, Commissioner Paul Caragiulo asked to open a discussion about the issue.

His fellow commissioners came to the quick conclusion that all Five Points Park benches should be removed.

“The Plaza at Five Points has the highest property-tax value in the county,” said Vice Mayor Terry Turner. “We need to be mindful in harming the property value.”

Said Commissioner Shannon Snyder: “There’s a difference between helping people and enabling people.”
And Mayor Suzanne Atwell said the time to act is now.

“We need to do something,” she said. “We have to pay attention to that neighborhood.”

The city’s park smoking ban will begin to be enforced in about a month. The city will remove the benches and study for three months after that what effect the removal has on the transient activity in the park.

A decision will be made after that time about keeping the benches out of the park or returning them.

Contact Robin Roy at

Login Register now

Currently 1 Response

  • 1.
  • Turning the Park Over to Transients

    I was shocked to read that the city of Sarasota has decided to turn the beautiful 5 - points park over to the transients. My husband and I live on the north-end of Longboat Key for almost 6 months during the winter and make a point of attending all the performances of the Sarasota Opera as well as making downtown Sarasota a destination point during our stay. We love sitting on the benches whenever we are early for an event or just growing weary of walking. Taking the benches away will guarantee that this beautiful section of Sarasota will be welcoming only to the transients. During the Chanukah celebrations last winter, it was obvious that there was not enough benches in the park!! Sarasota is one of our most favourite cities, please don't lock it up and throw away the key.
  • Joy Vogt
    Fri 20th May 2011
    at 10:04am
Login below to post a comment or click register.
Account E-Mail
forgot password? click here
Speak Your Mind Below!


Subscribe to our eNewsletters
1970 Main Street, Sarasota, FL 34236 941-366-3468

Copyright 2014 The Observer Group Inc., All Rights Reserved