Safety concerns surface in SUP proposal


Safety concerns surface in SUP proposal


Date: August 7, 2014
by: Jessica Salmond | Staff Writer


While the county considers allowing stand-up paddleboard rentals on public beaches, others are concerned with its affect on public safety.

The Sarasota County Commission received a proposal in February from Rob Alfieri, owner of SUP Sarasota and founder of the Sarasota SUP Race Series, to allow a vendor to rent boards at the beach.
Currently, paddleboarders can launch from any non-lifeguarded public beach access area. Watercrafts of any kind are prohibited on the lifeguarded sections of the beach, said Tricia Wisner, the business development coordinator for Sarasota County Parks and Recreation Department. There is about 2,400 feet of lifeguarded beach on Siesta Key.

The county is considering two options. The first is to reduce the swimming zone on the beach’s shoreline by 50 to 100 feet, thereby giving enough space to allow paddleboard launching, Wisner said. Vendors could then rent paddleboards to beachgoers on the public beach.

The second option is a vendor could rent paddleboards at non-lifeguarded beach access areas. Currently, people contact paddleboard rental companies, meet them at the beach access point and receive their boards, Wisner said.

The county held a public meeting Tuesday to inform the public about its ideas and to receive feedback.

“It’s a great sport, but the issue is doing it at lifeguarded beaches,” said Michael Shay, president of the Siesta Key Association.

Shay said he is not in favor of allowing paddleboards to be rented at the busy lifeguarded beaches because paddleboarders could potentially come in contact with swimmers.

If paddleboarders go beyond the swim zone in the Gulf, then they are at risk of encountering watercrafts such as Jet Skis, parasails and boats. Inexperienced paddleboarders might have a problem handling boat wakes, too.

“There are plenty of places to stand-up paddleboard,” Shay said.

Scott Montgomery, Sarasota County lifeguard manager, said the lifeguarding division would prefer not to allow paddleboarding near the swim zone because of the safety concern.

If a paddleboarder was not wearing a leash to the board and fell off, the board could fly out from under him and hit someone, he said.

Alfieri said there are ways to reduce the risks involved in paddleboarding. Some boards are made with soft tops and sides, and others are inflatable, therefore reducing the chance of injury should someone fall off or get hit with a board.

Alfieri said some people are already paddleboarding near the swim zone. The proposal would allow the county to regulate people’s actions.

Alfieri said the rental company at the Siesta Key Beach should provide supervision and training for renters. By providing training, safety instruction and guided tours, renters would reduce the risks of injury while providing a good experience to customers.

“It’s not just good business for the SUP vendor; it’s good promotion for Sarasota,” Alfieri said.

The Gulf draws paddleboarders because of the experience of being able to see in the open water and get a firsthand look at marine life, as well for the exercise, Alfieri said.

“It’s like yoga, meditation, going to the gym and going to the zoo all at one time,” he said.

The second public meeting will be held from 4 to 6:30 p.m. Tuesday, Aug. 12, at the Nokomis County Center, 234 E. Nippino Trail, Nokomis.


Login Register now

Currently 1 Response

  • 1.
  • If the US Coast Guard says its ok Sarasota should too! There is no reason to not allow SAFE SUP on the beaches. I have been hit with boogie boards and such by kids on the beach plenty of times....should we banish those too? Let's use common sense Sarasota...

    The Coast Guard has ruled on this at other beaches:
    New Coast Guard ruling a big victory for Stand Up Paddle Surfers. Prevents SUP’s from being banned in surf breaks

    HPWA Receives Coast Guard Clarification

    The Human Powered Watercraft Association has received a letter of clarification from the United States Coast Guard stating “If a paddleboard is used within a designated swimming, surfing or bathing area, the Coast Guard does not consider it to be a vessel.”

    HPWA Director Steven Alan Fry explains the importance of this distinction: “State and local agencies have long been using “vessel” status to segregate or ban the use of small watercraft such as wave skis, outriggers and canoes from popular swimming beaches and surf breaks. When the USCG applied vessel status to SUP’s it resulted in an unintended consequence where surfers carrying paddles were banned or restricted from many popular surfing locations.”

    The HPWA took the initiative to inform the Coast Guard of the problem and was successful in gaining this critical clarification. Now, paddle surfing cannot be banned or regulated in any way different from other kinds of surfing, and equal access must be provided.

    Fry continues”We are now contacting the various state and local agencies who currently regulate paddle surfing to inform them of the need to eliminate any and all bans or restrictions on paddle surfing in designated surfing areas.” Fry explains further “The surfing community must self-regulate SUP’s in the same manner as is done between short and long board surfers. Each and every wave is a public resource that has to be reasonably shared by all surfers regardless of how long their board is or whether they use a paddle.”

    Mickey Munoz, HPWA’s surf industry advisor adds his conclusion. “Paddle surfing is here to stay and everyone has to learn to share. SUP’s have to spread the aloha spirit and yield a reasonable balance of waves to the inner lineups. Nothing but common sense will prevail.”

    The Human Powered Watercraft Association is free to join and helps to support their efforts to protect, educate and promote all forms of human powered watercraft. Meet them on Facebook or join up at
  • Keffie Lancaster
    Fri 8th Aug 2014
    at 9:08am
Login below to post a comment or click register.
Account E-Mail
forgot password? click here
Speak Your Mind Below!


Subscribe to our eNewsletters
1970 Main Street, Sarasota, FL 34236 941-366-3468

Copyright 2015 The Observer Group Inc., All Rights Reserved