Village hosts candidate forum


Village hosts candidate forum


Date: March 4, 2010
by: Robin Hartill | Community Editor


The Longbeach Village Association hosted five of the six candidates for Longboat Key Town Commission at the group’s Wednesday, March 3, meeting. Candidates fielded questions from group members about issues facing the Key.

One resident asked the two current commissioners what progress had been made on cell-phone service and asked the three challengers what they would do to improve service.

“Technology is improving,” said District 3 Commissioner Peter O’Connor. “Technology here, of course, is not improving.”

Mayor Lee Rothenberg, who represents District 1, described himself as “broadly opposed” to cell-phone towers.

“My feeling is let’s be patient,” he said.

Phil Younger, who is running against Commissioner Hal Lenobel for the at-large seat, said the north end was in need of enhanced service. Lenobel did not attend the debate.

David Brenner, challenger for the District 3 seat, said a public group should examine issue in a forum.

“You don’t want to end up with a life-and-death situation where you have a cell phone that doesn’t work,” he said.

Lynn Larson, running against Rothenberg for the District 1 seat, scoffed at the idea that north-end residents should be patient as they wait for improvements.

“Patients belong in a hospital,” said Larson, suggesting the town could work with Manatee County officials to develop stealth solutions.

One attendee asked Larson if she stood by her past comments suggesting that commissioners should be paid.

“I do not ever want to get paid as a commissioner, but pay is not unreasonable,” Larson said. “Someone who needs a job should not be prohibited from running as a commissioner because of the time requirement.”

Brenner said a public group should look into the issue but noted he did not see anything wrong with paying commissioners.

Younger said he would prefer not to burden taxpayers with commissioner salaries.

O’Connor said when he was first elected to the commission, he attended lengthy training sessions for public officials. The group attending the session was polled and found Longboat Key was the only town for which commissioners were in attendance that didn’t pay its elected officials.

“That only-ness of ours works to our advantage,” O’Connor said. “I think our position is solid the way it is.”

Rothenberg said  he opposes pay for commissioners.

“It’s the labor of the heart,” he said. “We’re giving something back to the community now that we’re retired."

One resident asked commissioners about decaying, vacant properties that could result from declines in tourism and noted a recent report that tourism was up on Anna Maria Island but down on Longboat Key.

“Everybody is suffering, and there’s no quick answer,” Rothenberg said. “The answers lie in making Longboat the most attractive place in Florida so that people come here not just to live in condos six months out of the year but also as tourists.”

Younger suggested working with chambers of commerce to promote Longboat Key as a family-friendly place.

Brenner said residents should ask themselves how much tourism they want.

“Anna Maria Island is much more of a tourist town,” he said.

Larson said Longboat Key needs to be friendlier toward some type of development and said tourist units need to be replaced.

O’Connor said Anna Maria Island attracts different types of visitors than Longboat Key.

In response to a question about fixing the town’s pension plan, Younger said changes are needed to the current system.

Brenner expressed frustration that nothing has been done about the situation.

“The longer we delay, that $25 million liability continues to grow day by day,” he said.

Larson said the town could consider a switch to a defined contribution program while honoring commitments it made to current employees.

O’Connor said expecting a quick pension fix was unrealistic.

Both O’Connor and Rothenberg pointed out that a mortgage, like the pension plan, is an unfunded liability.

“Just like a mortgage, what you do is try to get a stable payment obligation,” Rothenberg said.

Contact Robin Hartill at

Login Register now

Currently 3 Responses

  • 1.
  • Talk is cheap! I am still waiting for a plan more viable than Longboat Key Club's offering? The fact is there is nothing else going on to bring more visitors to Longboat Key. Tourism is on the decline and 5 star visitors will be history in the future. They will be replaced with t-shirt shops and the weekend trunk tourists. I am also still looking for all that traffic coming out of The LBK Resort with their current 218 rooms? Don't let IPOC confuse you as the traffic backed up at 5PM is not The Resorts traffic. Blaming The Club is the great deception. I also want to remind everybody that we are in peak season.. Any traffic back up at 5PM is not coming from Longboat Key Resort but going North and South. I repeat, it is not The Club's traffic..... The 218 rooms in existence at the resort plus the current condos behind the gates do not clog the roadways both behind the gates and on Gulf of Mexico drive. The offer from Longboat Key Club is a once in a lifetime offer. Longboat Key is in desperate need of get it done leaders with a vision for the future.

    Rick Crawford, Positive Change Coalition

  • Rick Crawford
    Sat 6th Mar 2010
    at 12:45pm
  • 2.
  • Dear Observer,
    Thank you for the opportunity to meet the candidates and present issues relevant to many groups that contribute to life on the Key.
    I urge all citizens to attend the forums to compare and contrast these caring people vying for your vote.
    The Observer does a great service to our community by giving us these opportunities.
    Also, many thanks for highlighting in last week's issue the new and promising businesses that deserve our support. There are many things we can do to "keep Longboat Longboat" within our current framework.
    Sincerely, Jackie Salvino
  • jackie salvino
    Thu 4th Mar 2010
    at 6:36pm
  • 3.
  • Rothenberg said. “The answers lie in making Longboat the most attractive place in Florida so that people come here not just to live in condos six months out of the year but also as tourists.

    Well, I believe that the Longboat Key Club is trying to do exactly that. The Club has publicly professed what it can bring to this island if allowed to update and redevelop it's present operation. It seems everyone is only concerned about updating the present building codes with absolutely no regard that The Club is patiently waiting and holds in it's hands the "golden egg" for catapulting LBK into the next positive decade! What is IPOC prepared to bring to this island? What monies will IPOC offer toward the island economy? Will they match The Key Club with 5 to 6 Million in permit fee money? If so, that would be really cool! Let's get down to the nitty gritty...they are only concerned about their views!!! Is IPOC willing to pay the town over a million dollars in advertising fees every year to help "keep Longboat Longboat?" The Longboat Key Club spends that easily in a year's time. Again, how about if IPOC matches that advertising expense every year also? That would be pretty sweet too! Oh, and by the way, how about the beach renourishment? IPOC, you can also match the club on what they pay to renourish your beach that you have the luxury of looking out upon.
  • Marsha Crawford
    Thu 4th Mar 2010
    at 6:01pm
Login below to post a comment or click register.
Account E-Mail
forgot password? click here
Speak Your Mind Below!


Subscribe to our eNewsletters
1970 Main Street, Sarasota, FL 34236 941-366-3468

Copyright 2015 The Observer Group Inc., All Rights Reserved