Emerald Harbor resident and retired geological engineer Dr. Weldon Frost says oil-and-gas drilling off the shores of Longboat Key is a no-brainer.
But the 37-year Mobil Oil employee is quick to point out that he doesn’t believe oil will spout anywhere near the island’s shores.
Still, Frost doesn’t think it hurts to look.
At a Longboat Key Public Interest Committee debate on oil drilling held Thursday, Jan. 28, at the Longboat Key Hilton Beachfront Resort, Frost sparred off against Tallahassee-based Natural Resources Defense Council consultant Susan Glickman.
Glickman opened the debate by explaining an amendment filed in the Legislature last year to open up a former moratorium on offshore drilling on Florida’s Gulf Coast would destroy the state’s biggest industry.
Weldon, however, disputed Glickman’s claims by calling himself “a victim of his own experience.”
The retired geologist, who oversaw approximately 60 offshore drills with no incidents, said he was as much of an environmentalist as anyone else in the audience of approximately 55 people.
Frost said that 49,000 wells have been drilled in the Gulf, and there are currently 81 working oilrigs in the Gulf of Mexico.
“But the future of oil rigs in the Gulf is in deep water,” Frost said. “Forty-one of the 81 working rigs are in water depths of 1,000 feet and 15 are working in water depths of more than 5,000 feet.”
Frost stressed that he believes drilling is the right thing to do.
“This country imports approximately 70% of oil, while the Department of Energy that President Jimmy Carter created has grown to a budget of more than $24 billion,” Frost said. “We have no energy leadership.”
Frost said it bothers him that the United States spent $265 billion last year buying oil and spends $100 million per day to get oil from Venezuela.
But Glickman said Florida shouldn’t consider oil drilling, because the United States only has 3% of the world’s oil reserves.
“We can’t drill our way to energy security by getting a limited amount of oil,” Glickman said. “What we have to do is get away from oil.”
Glickman did agree with Frost that there’s not a whole lot of oil to be found between 3-to-10 miles off the Gulf coast.
“And if oil is found more than 10 miles offshore, the state couldn’t even get any money from the drilling rights because it’s currently not a revenue sharing state,” Glickman said.
And although the state’s energy association claims more than 24,000 jobs could be created if oil drilling is allowed off the coast, Glickman was quick to point out that even Frost said that only about 1,000 jobs would be created if oil were found off the coast.
Said Glickman: “Twenty-two oil wells were drilled off the state’s coast years ago and they all were dry. So why are we thinking about spending money to open up drilling where there’s no oil?”
Weldon, though, said he thinks companies should continue to drill everywhere.
“I think there’s a lower risk from oil spills than having two years of red tide back to back,” Frost said.
Frost received laughter from the audience when he said he found it funny that beach communities have no problem building a 10-story condominium “on a strip of pristine beach.”
“But those residents have no problem complaining about a tiny light that they see nine miles out on an oil rig at night,” Frost said.
Contact Kurt Schultheis at email@example.com
Currently 5 Responses
- I believe the pipes and platforms that could restrict our limited source of proper sand for beach renourishment is more concerning than adding to the sate revenues. Also if huricanes break off the platforms, the well does not leak but the pipes fillied with oil do as was the case with Katrina. Oil on the beaches would make red tide seem like paradise.
- Dr. Frost is far from being an idiot. He knows that we have to drill in our own yards if we are ever to be less dependent on foreign resources. The rigs would not be seeable from our shores. Anyone who thinks they will knows little or nothing about offshore drilling.
- Great artice and hats off to Dr Frost nice to see someone with comman sense. Not found with most of the 'part time resident owners here
Longboat will always be a nice island, however it comes at a cost
The island is built out its time to renourish and rebuild and get rid of nay sayers. They seem to be against everything related to progress.
However they all whine & complain and drive 15 miles off ilsand to buy cheap gas.
They want it Cheap, but can't see the flowers for the trees.
Drilling in the Gulf won't even be seen here.
Most are half blind anyway --Just watch then drive down GMD
- I would be willing to bet that most if not all of the people that are against offshore drilling are in favor of reducing our dependency on foreign oil.
The problem is that when it comes to making the sacrifices necessary to achieve that goal we always seem to want “the other guy” (e.g. Galveston) to pay the price.
- Dr. Frost is an idiot, if he wants to look at oil wells, let him move
1 Floridafitfest and 5K Treasure Run
9:00 am - 4:00 pm
8 World Oceans Day Family Festival
10:00 am - 1:00 pm
Miller shares Longboat lore
David Miller gave the Kiwanis Club of Longboat Key a history lesson Thursday, May 16, when he shared his memories of early island life.
Kiwanians get club recognition
The Kiwanis Club of Longboat Key recently received "Distinguished Club" status from Kiwanis International for its efforts during the 2011-12 year.
Hat's off to Dee Pelton, volunteers
Dee Pelton held a luncheon that will be tough to top.