This is one of those times when you wouldn’t want to be a member of the city’s Public Art Committee or its City Commission.
No matter what the members of these two bodies decide about the fate of Seward Johnson’s sculpture of Alfred Eisenstaedt’s extraordinary 1945 photograph, “V-J Day in Times Square,” they cannot win. The emotions on both sides are too volatile.
The “pros” and “cons” seem almost equally weighted.
In all of our years in Sarasota, we have never seen anything consistently draw people to Sarasota’s bayfront and consistently generate the happiness and joy that “Unconditional Surrender” has. It brings life to the bayfront.
It evokes a love of country, a love of Americanism, a reminder of who we are and of a time that was so extraordinary. We won. We won, gosh dangit! And that kiss told the whole story.
What’s wrong with all of that? What possibly could be wrong with celebrating all of that in the most conspicuous location in our city?
Purist-artists may hate “Unconditional Surrender” for its kitsch-ness, but in terms of visual interest, it certainly packs much more punch than the tall red-steel sculpture that for months stood unnoticed next to the big smooch.
So lighten up, naysayers and cranks. Gosh knows, Sarasota could use some livening up, a draw that attracts people, conversation and action.
What’s more, think creatively. It doesn’t have to stay in the exact location it stands today. Imagine a better context, a park-like design that gives it a better anchor and surroundings on the bayfront. To move it anywhere else most assuredly will kill its joyful effects.
Sarasota resident Denise Kowal raises an important consideration (see My View, page 7): Integrity.
Imagine if Eisenstadt were alive today and, to his surprise, learned that Johnson had converted his photograph to a giant, three-dimensional sculpture without asking. Imagine if you were an Eisenstadt heir.
This is troubling. The issue of copyright infringement has dogged Johnson’s “Unconditional Surrender” from the start.
This makes it an issue for the Public Art Committee and the City Commission. As a member of one of these bodies, before making a decision involving public property, we would want to know: Do the owners of the copyright have objections to this work or the display of it?
What often seems simple never is. As the discussions begin on the sculpture’s fate, those making the final decision first should have all of the facts.
Be wise, not emotional.
Currently 0 Responses
20 First Responders Community Day
10:00 am - 2:00 pm
24 Food Fight
6:00 am - 11:00 pm
26 Lakewood Ranch Republican Club Luncheon
12:00 pm - 1:00 pm
27 KidsCreate: Outdoor Pinting for Children
9:00 am - 11:00 am
Cardinal Mooney alumni plan reunion
Did you go to Cardinal Mooney in 1964? Your former classmates are calling for you!
Looming event aids in cancer cause
Learning Express Toys partnered with the MaxLove Project Sept. 13 and Sept. 14 for a special MaxLove International Loom-A-Thon Against Cancer.
MTI hosts 9/11 blood drive
As the nation remembers the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, Manatee Technical Institute will commemorate the tragedy with a blood drive from 8:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. Sept. 10 and Sept. 11, at its main campus, 6305 State Road 70 East, in front of Braden River High Schol.