This week’s hand features an astonishing defense by West — we’ll get to the winning play by degrees.
E-W did well not to compete to 3 (spades) (that contract is down one if N-S get their Diamond ruff). Instead, E-W are required to defeat South’s 3 (hearts) contract. Will they? West’s lead is a Spade, which is won in Dummy.
In the first degree, you are Declarer. With that running Diamond suit you have loads of winners, but the danger is that E-W will get five tricks first. You can try for a Club ruff in Dummy, but alert defenders will switch to trumps (being sure to hold up the A (hearts) until the second round). Nonetheless, at trick two, you lead a Club hoping that something good will happen.
In the second degree, you are East trying to thwart Declarer. Dummy’s A (spades) wins the first trick, and a Club is led, won by West’s Jack. West shifts to a trump, and you have a dilemma:
• If Declarer has the A (clubs), and West the A (diamonds), then the winning defense is to take the A (hearts) immediately and play another Heart, stopping the Club ruff.
• If Declarer has the A (diamonds) and West the A (clubs), then the winning defense is to duck the first trump, win the next Club, cash A (hearts) and then a third Club.
To bring home the bacon, the defense must go to the third degree. This time, you are West, trying to help East thwart Declarer. It is the same start, but instead of routinely winning the J (clubs) at trick two, you do some thinking. Declarer did not play Clubs like someone holding the K (clubs), so East surely has that card. In that case you can afford to squander the Ace! This brilliant stroke solves East’s dilemma, telling him what he needs to know. How many Wests would find that truly remarkable play? None that we know of!
Click here to view this week's bridge page.